• linear-gradient(to bottom, #FF99EB 0%, #FFAB71 100%)
  • Stacked Magic Spoon protein pastry boxes in chocolate, cinnamon, and strawberry flavors with hands holding individual pastrie
  • Individual pastry with white drizzle held by person against purple background with nutritional information displayed.
  • Three pastry flavors displayed: Frosted Strawberry with red frosting, Cinnamon Brown Sugar with cinnamon coating, and S'mores
  • S'mores pastry with graham cracker, red filling, and white marshmallow drizzle on purple background with microwave and toaste
  • Three pastries shown three ways: one on a colorful plate, one held with a fork over steam, and one in a sealed package on an
  • Purple promotional insert featuring "Magic Spoon" branding, five gold stars, and customer testimonials on white text boxes.
  • Three pastry nutrition labels for frosted strawberry, cinnamon brown sugar, and s'mores flavors.

Variety 6

Protein Pastries - 24 Pastries

Soft-baked, frosted pastries with nostalgic flavor, baked smarter. Protein Pastries deliver the classic pastry experience you remember, with a modern nutritional twist. Each pastry is soft and satisfying, made with protein + fiber 💪 and at least 80 % less sugar* than the leading toaster pastry so you can enjoy a feel-good treat any time of day.

  • Check 11g Protein
  • Check 6g Fiber
  • Check 3g Sugar
  • Check No Artificial Flavors
Original price
$58.50
Discounted price
$55.50

Try risk-free, 100% happiness guaranteed. See terms of use.

Don't Miss Out!

Combine Favorites.
Save More.

Build your own box with protein cereal, oatmeal, granola, treats, and pastries.

build your own
Decorative bottom shape
linear-gradient(to bottom, #FF99EB 0%, #FFAB71 100%)

Variety 6

Protein Pastries - 24 Pastries
4.6
Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars
31,061 Reviews

Breakfast With Benefits™

High Protein

High Protein

Packed with 11g of
protein per pastry

High Fiber

High Fiber

Gut-friendly with
6g fiber per pastry

80% Less Sugar*

80% Less Sugar*

Deliciously sweet
without the crash

No Synthetic Dyes

No Synthetic Dyes

Grain-free, gluten-free
+ 5g net carb per pastry

Proof They’re as Good as They Look

Soft texture, indulgent filling


"These completely exceeded my expectations, knowing what others in market taste like."


Lillian

Nostalgic but better!



"I've tried other protein pastries and this is simply the best choice in that category."

Karin S

Cleaner ingredient list



"Tastes like a Saturday-morning classic from childhood."


Allison

Founder story desktop image Founder story mobile image
Top Image

Ways To Enjoy

Enjoy As Is

Enjoy As Is

Remove from wrapper and enjoy as is!

Microwave

Microwave

Remove from wrapper and place on a microwave safe plate. Microwave in 10 second intervals or until warm. Let cool before enjoying!

Toaster Oven

Toaster Oven

Remove from wrapper and place horizontally on toaster oven tray. Heat on lowest setting for 1 min or until warm. Let cool before enjoying!

Frozen

Frozen

Place in freezer for 20 minutes. Remove from wrapper and savor frosty deliciousness!

Caution

Caution

Do not use a vertical toaster. The frosting may melt down and burn.

Us Vs Them

How do we stack up to the "classics"?

Protein
Fiber
Sugar
Serving Size
Gluten and Grain Free
No artificial flavors
11g
6g
3g
56g
Leading Toaster Pastry
5g
1g
31g
96g

Competitive Information As Of January 2026
*Than the leading Toaster Pastry competitor

What Spooners are saying

4.6
Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars
Based on 31,061 reviews
Write a Review (Opens in a new tab)
31,061 reviews
  • Alicia C.
    Verified Buyer
    4 minutes ago
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    So far, so good!

    We chose the variety box. We have only tried the fruity and the honey nut, so far. We like the flavor, the fact that they stay crunchy, and the added bonus of the protein. It's a win, win all the way around.

    Was this helpful?
  • Yohanni O.
    Verified Buyer
    5 hours ago
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    Very tasty I love the cereal

    It is little pricey but i like the taste of the cereal

    Was this helpful?
  • Tina T.
    Verified Buyer
    Yesterday
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    Taste

    Love the taste of all the cerals

    Was this helpful?
  • Paula D. P.
    Verified Buyer
    2 days ago
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    Better than the National Brand

    Siblings have the National Brand, but those have too many carbs and sugar for a T1D toddler. This is a perfect replacement.

    Was this helpful?
  • Paula D. P.
    Verified Buyer
    2 days ago
    Rated 5 out of 5 stars
    Great Value

    Bought multiple items for my T1D toddler.

    Was this helpful?

Frequently Asked Questions

We wanted to create a pastry that hits all of those nostalgic flavor notes from your childhood, all while delivering on the macros you need to fuel your grown-up body. We think we’ve cracked the code, and we can’t wait to hear what you think!

Magic Spoon Pastries are great straight out of the package, heated in the microwave (Our teams favorite), toasted in a toaster oven*, or even frozen!

*don’t heat in a vertical toaster!

Our Protein Pastries have 3g total sugar per pastry (that’s at least 80% less sugar* than the leading toaster pastry)!

*than the leading toaster pastry competitor.

You can find our Protein Pastries here on our website, as well as in select retailers nationwide! Check out our store locator here to find a store near you.

While our protein pastries don’t contain nuts, they are manufactured in a facility that processes peanuts, sesame, and other tree nuts.

We wanted to create a pastry that hits all of those nostalgic flavor notes from your childhood, all while delivering on the macros you need to fuel your grown-up body. We think we’ve cracked the code, and we can’t wait to hear what you think!

We've spent years perfecting our recipes in our quest to reimagine our favorite childhood breakfasts and snacks, swapping sugar and grains for high quality protein sources and natural sweeteners. Try all of our products to fuel your own kind of high-protein, gluten-free, keto-friendly magic!

View more FAQ's ›